July 12, 2008 – 9:29 am
Right now we’re in the process of doing through a rebranding, with a new firm name, logo, and website. As part of that process, we have registered several new domain names and need to purchase new SSL certificates for our webmail, SSL VPN, and client portal website. Previously I used GoDaddy for our webmail site (OWA), but as I’ve been researching I’ve realized that certificates have gotten much more complicated the past few years.
The first challenge is picking a Certificate Authority (CA). Pick the wrong one, and at best your users will get a warning message that the certificate is not recognized as being valid. At worst, their application just won’t work. After using GoDaddy, I realized several things. One, is that GoDaddy’s root CA isn’t recognized on Windows Mobile 5 devices. This meant I had to manually install the certificates on all of our older Motorola Q phones. Second, Windows Mobile 5 doesn’t recognize wildcard certificates, whichleads to my next challenge. There is also a huge discrepancy in the pricing between CAs. VeriSign, which has the most brand recognization, is easily 3-5 times more expensive than GoDaddy or other cheaper CAs.You may pay more in the long-term, however, as GoDaddy doesn’t allow reissuing certificates like some of the more expensive CAs do. If you make a mistake in your request (such as the wrong common name), your certificate is effectively worthless.
The second challenge is picking the correct cert. There are basic, wildcard, EV (Extended Validation), and multiple common or alternate name certs. Wildcard certs are valid for all subdomains for company.com. EV certificates were created in 2006 to help fight against phishing attacks, and are a more expensive certificate that requires a much more rigorous process for validation. Modern browsers (Firefox and IE7+) recognize EVs with a green shading on the address bar. Multiple common or alternate name certs allow you to protect several subdomains (but not all) with one certificate.
All of this leads me to how do you chose an SSL certificate? Choosing the CA is obviously important, but you also have to insure you pick the right certificate as well. I haven’t decided who I am going with this round, but I know it won’t be GoDaddy.
Posted in IT, Work | 3 Comments »